NYC Cooling Tower System Inspection Results

1022699

2000012181

729 SEVENTH AVE

Manhattan

10019

Active

1

2021-07-27T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1010017501

40.760096

-73.983973

105

4

012500

MN0502

1022699

2000012182

729 SEVENTH AVE

Manhattan

10019

Active

1

2023-07-27T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1010017501

40.760096

-73.983973

105

4

012500

MN0502

1026676

2000012488

430 W 51ST ST

Manhattan

10019

Active

1

2021-12-13T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1010607502

40.764374

-73.990134

104

03

013300

MN0402

3421373

2000000296

229 DUFFIELD STREET

Brooklyn

11201

Active

1

2022-10-06T00:00:00.000

AH8T

24 RCNY §8-05(f)(4)

Failure to monitor and sample from representative locations and times

Critical

At the time of inspection, Respondent failed to produce records demonstrating proof of water quality monitoring and sampling locations. Respondent failed to produce records demonstrating required times of water quality monitoring. Respondent failed to produce records of required locations for bacteriological indicator samples collected on the following dates: pertinent records not provided Respondent failed to provide records of bacteriological indicator sampling times for samples collected on the following date(s): pertinent records not provided Respondent failed to provide records of locations of Legionella sampling. Sampling locations were not provided for samples collected on the following date(s): pertinent records not provided Respondent failed to provide records of Legionella sampling collection times. Sampling times were not provided for samples collected on: pertinent records not provided

0881278348

Cycle

3001460014

40.691221

-73.984105

302

22

001502

BK0202

3421373

2000000296

229 DUFFIELD STREET

Brooklyn

11201

Active

1

2022-10-06T00:00:00.000

AH8X

24 RCNY §8-06(b)(2)

Legionella samples not collected, analyzed before system start-up

General

At the time of inspection, Respondent failed to produce sufficient evidence in the form of a lab report or chain-of-custody form that the required startup Legionella culture test had been completed during the documented startup time period: pertinent records not provided

0881278357

Cycle

3001460014

40.691221

-73.984105

302

22

001502

BK0202

3421373

2000000296

229 DUFFIELD STREET

Brooklyn

11201

Active

1

2021-11-03T00:00:00.000

AH8S

24 RCNY §8-05(f)(3)

Legionella samples not collected or analyzed, or results not recorded or reported to DOHMH as required

PHH

At the time of inspection, Respondent failed to demonstrate by either lab report or chain of custody form that all required Legionella samples were taken while the cooling tower system was in operation. At the time of inspection Legionella sample record for a post-corrective action, which was due by 09/09/2020, was not taken within 3-7 days after the corrective action for Level 2 Legionella result taken on 08/10/2020 (24.00 CFU/ml).

0881259419

Cycle

3001460014

40.691221

-73.984105

302

22

001502

BK0202

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2023-06-13T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2022-06-08T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-06-02T00:00:00.000

AH8B

24 RCNY §8-03

Maintenance Program and Plan incomplete or not on premises

Critical

Respondent is in violation of 24 RCNY 8-03 in that the MPP was not made available at the date and time of inspection noted above. The on-site representative was requested to provide missing record during inspection and at final review of violation deficiencies but was not able to do so.

0881250251

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-06-02T00:00:00.000

AH8C

24 RCNY §8-04(a)

Routine monitoring not conducted, documented at least once a week when tower is in use

Critical

Respondent is in violation of 24 RCNY 8-04(a)(1) in that the operational records provided by on-site representative and reviewed by Department at the time of inspection failed to demonstrate that all weekly routine system monitoring had taken place while the cooling tower system was in operation.

0881250260

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-06-02T00:00:00.000

AH8D

24 RCNY §8-04(b)

Compliance inspections not conducted, documented at least once every 90 days when the tower is in use

Critical

Compliance inspections must be completed by a Qualified Person every 90 days while the cooling tower system is in operation. Respondent is in violation of 24 RCNY 8-04(b) in that records provided by on-site representative and reviewed by Department at the time of inspection failed to provide documentation of compliance inspection(s) for the 90 day period prior to the following date(s): pertinent records not provided

0881250270

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-06-02T00:00:00.000

AH8E

24 RCNY §8-04(c)

Routine maintenance according to Maintenance Program and Plan not conducted or documented

General

At the time of inspection, operational records provided by on-site representative and reviewed by Department failed to demonstrate proof that routine maintenance was conducted or documented for the following date(s) while the cooling tower system was in operation: pertinent records not provided

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-06-02T00:00:00.000

AH8F

24 RCNY §8-04(d)

Twice yearly or other required cleaning not conducted or documented

Critical

At the time of inspection, operational records provided by on-site representative and reviewed by the Department failed to demonstrate proof that cleaning was conducted at all within the previous year of cooling tower operation.

0881250289

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-06-02T00:00:00.000

AH8H

24 RCNY §8-05(a)

Daily automatic or approved alternative water treatment plan not provided

Critical

At the time of inspection, upon review of operational records provided by on-site representative and Inspector's physical observation of the operating cooling tower system, Respondent failed to provide proof of either documentation of chemical treatment during cooling tower system operation, or a DOHMH approved alternative water treatment plan that justified the absence of chemical treatment.

0881250298

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-06-02T00:00:00.000

AH8L

24 RCNY §8-05(c)(3)

No records of all chemicals and biocides (C&B) added

Critical

At the time of inspection, upon Inspector's request for and complete review of records, Respondent failed to provide chemical and biocide usage records or safety data sheets (SDS) noting manufacturer's name, brand and purpose for chemicals used on-site.

0881250307

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1090946

2000012555

50 BOWERY

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-12-17T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1002020023

40.715755

-73.996378

103

01

002902

MN0301

3080697

2000012558

1501 PITKIN AVE

Brooklyn

11212

Active

1

2022-01-28T00:00:00.000

Cycle

3034920001

40.668924

-73.91784

316

41

090000

BK1602

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-06-02T00:00:00.000

AH8Q

24 RCNY §8-05(f)(1)

Minimum daily water quality measurements not taken or recorded (or if automated, not viewable)

General

Manual measurements of water quality parameter must occur at least 3 times each week while the cooling tower system is operating, as per §8-05(f)(1)(A). Operational records produced by on-site representative and reviewed by Department at the time of inspection failed to demonstrate that the manual collection of water quality parameters of re-circulating water was attempted or completed while the cooling tower system was in operation. Operational records produced by on-site representative and reviewed by Department at the time of inspection failed to demonstrate that the required automatic collection of water quality parameters of re-circulating water was conducted for the previous year while the cooling tower system was in operation, as per §8-05(f)(1)(B).

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-06-02T00:00:00.000

AH8R

24 RCNY §8-05(f)(2)

Failure to collect, analyze or record weekly biological process control indicators

Critical

At the time of inspection, and upon Inspector's request for records and complete review of Respondent's cooling tower records as produced by its on-site representative, Respondent failed to demonstrate that the required weekly collection of bacteriological indicators of re-circulating water was attempted or completed while the cooling tower system was in operation. On-site representative was requested to provide missing records during inspection and at final review of violation deficiencies but was not able to do so.

0881250316

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-06-02T00:00:00.000

AH8S

24 RCNY §8-05(f)(3)

Legionella samples not collected or analyzed, or results not recorded or reported to DOHMH as required

PHH

At the time of inspection, records provided by on-site representative and reviewed by Department failed to demonstrate by either lab report or chain of custody form that the required collection of Legionella samples were taken while the cooling tower system was in operation.

0881250325

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-06-02T00:00:00.000

AH8T

24 RCNY §8-05(f)(4)

Failure to monitor and sample from representative locations and times

Critical

Respondent is in violation of 24 RCNY 8-05(f)(4) records produced by on-site representative and reviewed by Department at the time of inspection failed to demonstrate proof of water quality monitoring and sampling locations, the times of water quality monitoring, and missing required sampling locations and bacteriological indicator sampling times for bacteriological indicator sample(s) collected on the following date(s): pertinent records not provided. At the time of inspection, records provided by on-site representative and reviewed by Department indicated that locations of Legionella sampling were missing. Sampling locations were not provided for samples collected on the following date(s): pertinent records not provided. At the time of inspection and upon the Department's review of Legionella sampling records provided by on-site representative, Respondent failed to provide Legionella sampling collection times for samples collected on: pertinent records not provided

0881250334

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-06-02T00:00:00.000

AH8X

24 RCNY §8-06(b)(2)

Legionella samples not collected, analyzed before system start-up

General

At the time of inspection, operational records provided by Respondent failed to produce sufficient evidence in the form of a lab report or chain-of-custody form that the required startup-up Legionella culture collection had been conducted during the following documented startup time period: pertinent records not provided

0881250343

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-06-02T00:00:00.000

AH8E

24 RCNY §8-04(c)

Routine maintenance according to Maintenance Program and Plan not conducted or documented

General

At the time of inspection, operational records provided by on-site representative and reviewed by Department failed to demonstrate proof that routine maintenance was conducted or documented for the following date(s) while the cooling tower system was in operation: pertinent records not provided

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-06-02T00:00:00.000

AH8Q

24 RCNY §8-05(f)(1)

Minimum daily water quality measurements not taken or recorded (or if automated, not viewable)

General

Manual measurements of water quality parameter must occur at least 3 times each week while the cooling tower system is operating, as per §8-05(f)(1)(A). Operational records produced by on-site representative and reviewed by Department at the time of inspection failed to demonstrate that the manual collection of water quality parameters of re-circulating water was attempted or completed while the cooling tower system was in operation. Operational records produced by on-site representative and reviewed by Department at the time of inspection failed to demonstrate that the required automatic collection of water quality parameters of re-circulating water was conducted for the previous year while the cooling tower system was in operation, as per §8-05(f)(1)(B).

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2021-04-14T00:00:00.000

Non-Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1002013

2000000297

155 FRANKLIN ST

Manhattan

10013

Active

1

2020-10-28T00:00:00.000

AH8S

24 RCNY §8-05(f)(3)

Legionella samples not collected or analyzed, or results not recorded or reported to DOHMH as required

PHH

At the time of inspection, records provided by on-site representative and reviewed by Department failed to demonstrate by either lab report or chain of custody form that the required collection of Legionella samples were taken while the cooling tower system was in operation. Legionella sample records were missing for the 90 day period prior to the following date(s): 02/19/2020

0881217628

Cycle

1001797503

40.719015

-74.008095

101

01

003300

MN0102

1087613

2000000298

200 11TH AVE

Manhattan

10011

Active

1

2022-06-23T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1006957506

40.749248

-74.006392

104

3

009901

MN0401

1087613

2000000298

200 11TH AVE

Manhattan

10011

Active

1

2020-08-07T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1006957506

40.749248

-74.006392

104

3

009901

MN0401

4003448

2000000301

47-47 VAN DAM STREET

Queens

11101

Active

1

2023-09-28T00:00:00.000

Cycle

4002530001

40.741484

-73.933708

402

26

019901

QN0202

4003448

2000000301

47-47 VAN DAM STREET

Queens

11101

Active

1

2022-12-08T00:00:00.000

Cycle

4002530001

40.741484

-73.933708

402

26

019901

QN0202

4003448

2000000301

47-47 VAN DAM STREET

Queens

11101

Active

1

2021-12-02T00:00:00.000

Cycle

4002530001

40.741484

-73.933708

402

26

019901

QN0202

4003448

2000000301

47-47 VAN DAM STREET

Queens

11101

Active

1

2020-02-18T00:00:00.000

Cycle

4002530001

40.741484

-73.933708

402

26

019901

QN0202

1024900

2000000302

3 COLUMBUS CIRCLE

Manhattan

10019

Active

1

2024-01-29T00:00:00.000

Non-Cycle

1010297501

40.766879

-73.982213

105

3

013700

MN0502

1024900

2000000302

3 COLUMBUS CIRCLE

Manhattan

10019

Active

1

2024-01-11T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1010297501

40.766879

-73.982213

105

3

013700

MN0502

1024900

2000000302

3 COLUMBUS CIRCLE

Manhattan

10019

Active

1

2022-04-06T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1010297501

40.766879

-73.982213

105

3

013700

MN0502

1024900

2000000302

3 COLUMBUS CIRCLE

Manhattan

10019

Active

1

2021-08-17T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1010297501

40.766879

-73.982213

105

3

013700

MN0502

2044222

2000000303

1695 EASTCHESTER ROAD

Bronx

10461

Active

1

2023-03-08T00:00:00.000

Cycle

2040850180

40.846476

-73.845217

211

13

020000

BX1001

2044222

2000000303

1695 EASTCHESTER ROAD

Bronx

10461

Active

1

2022-03-29T00:00:00.000

Cycle

2040850180

40.846476

-73.845217

211

13

020000

BX1001

2044222

2000000303

1695 EASTCHESTER ROAD

Bronx

10461

Active

1

2021-07-06T00:00:00.000

Cycle

2040850180

40.846476

-73.845217

211

13

020000

BX1001

2044222

2000000303

1695 EASTCHESTER ROAD

Bronx

10461

Active

1

2020-09-22T00:00:00.000

Cycle

2040850180

40.846476

-73.845217

211

13

020000

BX1001

1090129

2000000304

135 W 30TH ST

Manhattan

10001

Active

1

2023-04-17T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1008060013

40.7482

-73.991212

105

3

010100

MN0501

1090129

2000000304

135 W 30TH ST

Manhattan

10001

Active

1

2022-04-06T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1008060013

40.7482

-73.991212

105

3

010100

MN0501

1090129

2000000304

135 W 30TH ST

Manhattan

10001

Active

1

2021-07-14T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1008060013

40.7482

-73.991212

105

3

010100

MN0501

1090129

2000000304

135 W 30TH ST

Manhattan

10001

Active

1

2020-01-30T00:00:00.000

AH8B

24 RCNY §8-03

Maintenance Program and Plan incomplete or not on premises

Critical

Respondent is in violation of 24 RCNY 8-03 in that the MPP provided by on-site representative was missing the following elements: Owner Name; Owner Phone; Preparer Name;Respondent is in violation of 24 RCNY 8-03(d)(1) in that the MPP provided by on-site representative and reviewed by the Department was missing the following required routine system monitoring elements: Wetted Surfaces; Tower Basins; Drift Eliminators; Chemical Dosing/Control Equipment; Chemical Storage; Bleed-Off / Blow-down; Visible Contaminants;Respondent is in violation of 24 RCNY 8-03(d)(1) in that the MPP provided by on-site representative and reviewed by the Department was missing the required description of a routine system monitoring schedule.Respondent is in violation of 24 RCNY 8-03(d)(1) in that the MPP provided by on-site representative and reviewed by the Department was missing the following required routine maintenance elements: General System Cleanliness; Drift Eliminator Condition; Fill Material Condition; Distribution Operations; Water Treatment System; Basin/Remote Sump Cleaning; Stagnant/Low-Flow Zone Purging.Respondent is in violation of 24 RCNY 8-03(d)(1) in that the MPP provided by on-site representative and reviewed by the Department was missing the required description of a routine maintenance schedule.Respondent is in violation of 24 RCNY 8-03(a) in that the MPP provided by on-site representative did not include responsibilities for the following identified MPP team members: Building management company or owner; Qualified person;Respondent is in violation of 24 RCNY 8-03(a) in that the MPP provided by on-site representative and reviewed by Department did not include notification procedures for the following control measures: Routine System and Water Quality Monitoring; Compliance Inspections; Routine Maintenance and Part Replacement; Biological Sampling Results;

0881199047

Cycle

1008060013

40.7482

-73.991212

105

3

010100

MN0501

4181517

2000000359

8439 JAMAICA AVENUE

Queens

11421

Active

1

2018-03-06T00:00:00.000

Cycle

4088530105

40.69272

-73.859512

409

32

001200

QN0905

1090129

2000000304

135 W 30TH ST

Manhattan

10001

Active

1

2020-01-30T00:00:00.000

AH8E

24 RCNY §8-04(c)

Routine maintenance according to Maintenance Program and Plan not conducted or documented

General

At the time of inspection, operational records provided by on-site representative and reviewed by Department indicated discrepancies between the following routine maintenance elements in the MPP and operational records: General System Cleanliness; Drift Eliminator Condition; Fill Material Condition; Distribution Operations; Water Treatment System; Basin/Remote Sump Cleaning; Stagnant/Low-Flow Zone Purging.

Cycle

1008060013

40.7482

-73.991212

105

3

010100

MN0501

1090129

2000000304

135 W 30TH ST

Manhattan

10001

Active

1

2020-01-30T00:00:00.000

AH8F

24 RCNY §8-04(d)

Twice yearly or other required cleaning not conducted or documented

Critical

At the time of inspection, operational records provided by on-site representative and reviewed by the Department for previous year failed to demonstrate proof that a required cleaning was conducted within the following operational time period: Only one record provided for 2019. One more is missing in 2019.

0881199056

Cycle

1008060013

40.7482

-73.991212

105

3

010100

MN0501

1090129

2000000304

135 W 30TH ST

Manhattan

10001

Active

1

2020-01-30T00:00:00.000

AH8J

24 RCNY §8-05(c)(1)

Use of an unqualified biocide applicator

General

At the time of inspection, records provided by on-site representative and reviewed by the Department failed to include the DEC license number of the individual who performs the disinfection or applies biocides in the cooling tower system.

Cycle

1008060013

40.7482

-73.991212

105

3

010100

MN0501

1090129

2000000304

135 W 30TH ST

Manhattan

10001

Active

1

2020-01-30T00:00:00.000

AH8U

24 RCNY §8-05(f)(5)

Required corrective actions not taken based on bacteriological results

PHH

At the time of inspection, operational records provided by on-site representative and reviewed by Department failed to demonstrate proof that required corrective actions as defined in Table 8-2 of Chapter 8 were conducted in response to elevated bacteriological indicator sampling (BIS) results collected on the following date(s): 08/12/2019,05/20/2019,04/29/2019,04/01/2019

0881199065

Cycle

1008060013

40.7482

-73.991212

105

3

010100

MN0501

1003140

2000000305

71 JACKSON STREET

Manhattan

10002

Active

1

2022-07-19T00:00:00.000

Cycle

1002430080

40.711243

-73.980886

103

1

000202

MN0302